Friday, April 11, 2014

2014 NFL Mock Draft

1.       Houston Texans    -    Jadeveon Clowney, South Carolina, DE, 6-5 266 lbs, Junior
The Texans definitely need to select a quarterback at some point in the Draft, but Clowney is the best player on the board, and he has the most potential of any prospect in the Draft. Clowney is big, fast, and he oozes with the potential to be one of the top defensive ends in the NFL. Look for Houston to convert Clowney to an Outside Linebacker if the team continues to employ a 3-4 defensive front. Clowney comes from a 4-3 defensive scheme at South Carolina, but, regardless, he should be able to adjust and become a playmaker.

2.       St. Louis Rams    -    Greg Robinson, Auburn, OT, 6-5 332 lbs, Sophomore 
Quarterback Sam Bradford is coming off an injury-riddled season and he will be looking to cement himself as the Rams’ long-term solution at Quarterback. St. Louis needs to find out if Bradford is “the guy” for their franchise, and there is not a better way to help that evaluation process than by drafting an impactful Offensive Tackle to protect Bradford. Robinson is very athletic for his size, he played against top competition in the SEC week-in and week-out, and he is a monstrous player – 6’5” 332 lbs is intimidating.

3.       Jacksonville Jaguars    -    Blake Bortles, UCF, QB, 6-5 232 lbs, Junior 
The Jaguars need a lot of help if they want to become relevant again. The Blaine Gabbert experiment over the past few seasons was a failure, and Chad Henne projects to be more of a back-up Quarterback, rather than the long-term starter. Of the three big-name quarterbacks in this draft, Bortles has the most potential. He makes some questionable decisions when he senses pressure, and he doesn’t have the quick release that most General Managers look for, but he works hard and strives to get better. During his career at UCF, he improved every season in comparison to the prior season, and if he and the Jaguars can be patient during the grooming process, Bortles could be a quality solution at Quarterback for years to come.

4.       Cleveland Browns    -    Sammy Watkins, Clemson, WR, 6-1 211 lbs, Junior
What a gift this would be! Pair standout Wide Receiver, Josh Gordon, with the electrifying Sammy Watkins…yes, please. The Browns haven’t been to the playoffs in nearly a decade, and they still have a huge question mark at the quarterback position, but you cannot pass-up Watkins if he’s available right here. Watkins is my #2 overall prospect in the Draft because he’s fast, agile, he makes big plays, he can play in the slot or out wide, and he is a smooth route-runner. In 3-4 years, Watkins will be one of the best wide receivers in the NFL, count on it.

5.       Oakland Raiders    -    Khalil Mack, Buffalo, OLB, 6-3 251 lbs, Senior 
The Silver & Black could go a number of directions with this pick: (1) pick the best player on the board, (2) pick a player at a needed position, or (3) trade down). The Raiders will probably field several offers in the trading circus that ensues in Round 1 of the Draft, but, if they decide to make a selection, they should pick Anthony Barr (UCLA) or Khalil Mack. I have Barr rated higher than Mack on my Draft Board, but most teams have indicated that they like Mack, so look for the Raiders to sure-up the need for some outside pass rushing help and select Mack, who’s a bull of a defensive player with a consistent motor.

6.       Atlanta Falcons    -    Jake Matthews, Texas A&M, OT, 6-6 308 lbs, Senior
Watch for the Falcons to improve their offensive line with this pick and select the NFL-ready Jake Matthews. Many scouts felt that Matthews would have been selected higher than former teammate, Luke Joeckel, if Matthews chose to enter the Draft last year. When reviewing the tape of Matthews, one thing that is hard not to notice is his consistency. He plays hard on every down, he rarely makes mistakes, and he has great pass-blocking and running-blocking mechanics.

7.       Tampa Bay Buccaneers    -    Mike Evans, Texas A&M, WR, 6-5 231 lbs, Sophomore 
Welcome to Tampa Bay, Mike Evans! This would be an excellent selection by the Buccaneers and it would give a dynamic offensive threat to whoever Tampa Bay decides to play at Quarterback. Evans is a huge wide receiver, he has great hands, and plays with a mean streak that NFL teams covet. Evans projects to be an instant contributor and he has the potential to be a Pro Bowler.

8.       Minnesota Vikings    -    Teddy Bridgewater, Louisville, QB, 6-2 214 lbs, Junior
The Vikings need a Quarterback. Bridgewater is a less risky option than Johnny Manziel at the #8 spot in the Draft, and Vikings Head Coach, Mike Zimmer, has already disclosed that he isn’t a fan of Manziel. Bridgewater probably won’t be an impactful, game-changing Quarterback for 2-3 years, but he projects to be a better solution at the position than what the Vikings are currently working with on their roster. Bridgewater is tough, he’s accurate in the short-medium range passing game, and he makes good decisions with the football.

9.       Buffalo Bills    -    Eric Ebron, North Carolina, TE, 6-4 250 lbs, Junior
The Chicago Cubs of the NFL…the Buffalo Bills. In the 2013 Draft, Buffalo selected E.J. Manuel (Quarterback) with their first round pick, and he seems to be the short-term solution at Quarterback that Buffalo hopes to convert to the long-term solution. Manuel was selected 1-2 rounds higher than most analysts projected, and the Bills have a habit of selecting players higher than most analysts and scouts expect, so nothing is out-of-the-question with this pick. Should the Bills elect to be conservative and pick a quality player who will help Manuel and the Buffalo offense, they will pick Ebron here. Ebron is athletic, he plays with tenacity, and he possesses great techniques when running routes and catching the ball. His effectiveness as a blocker will be a work-in-progress.

10.   Detroit Lions    -    Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama, FS, 6-1 208 lbs, Junior
One of the best names in NFL Draft history will be a much-needed addition to the Detroit secondary. Clinton-Dix is a talented Free Safety with the “centerfielder’s ability” that defensive coordinators crave. At Alabama, he was coached by one of the best defensive minds in the college game, Nick Saban, and Saban’s tutelage will be invaluable to Clinton-Dix’s ability to be an instant contributor for the Lions. Blessed with speed, great instincts, and playmaking ability, Clinton-Dix should be a starter from Day 1.

11.   Tennessee Titans    -    Anthony Barr, UCLA, OLB, 6-5 255 lbs, Senior
If Barr falls down this far, he could be the steal of the Draft! One of the most athletic, physical specimens that has played at the college level in recent memory, Barr will be a force on the defensive side of the ball for Tennessee for years to come. Barr converted from Fullback to Outside Linebacker before the 2012 College Football season and he did not disappoint, constantly harassing opposing quarterbacks and making plays behind the line of scrimmage. Barr works hard, plays with tenacity, and he can be a ring-leader of a defense. NFL Comparison: Jevon Kearse (minus the injuries).

12.   New York Giants    -    Taylor Lewan, Michigan, OT, 6-7 309 lbs, Senior 
This pick is one of the “no brainers” in this Draft. If Lewan is available at #12, the Giants will select him. Lewan is battle-tested after starting on Michigan’s offensive line over the past four years, and he’s a consistent pass-blocker (although a developing run-blocker). Lewan will give Eli Manning a much-needed anchor on the offensive line. If Lewan had entered the 2013 NFL Draft, he would have been selected in the Top 3.

13.   St. Louis Rams    -    Darqueze Dennard, Michigan State, CB, 5-11 199 lbs, Senior
With their second pick in Round 1, look for St. Louis to add some depth to their secondary and select either Darqueze Dennard or Justin Gilbert (Oklahoma State). Both players would have likely been selected in the Top 12 in the 2013 Draft, but because the 2014 Draft has so much depth, both players will likely fall to the mid-late teens. Dennard won the Jim Thorpe Award last season at Michigan State and he was a true “Shutdown Corner” for the Spartans. The Rams could also look at adding another offensive threat for Sam Bradford to use in the passing game with this pick, such as Marqise Lee (USC) or Odell Beckham Jr. (LSU).

14.   Chicago Bears    -    C.J. Mosley, Alabama, MLB, 6-2 234 lbs, Senior
The next Brian Urlacher in Chicago? Mosley has the talent and the leadership traits necessary for that type of productive tenure, but will the Bears grab Mosley here or elect to pick a Defensive Tackle like Aaron Donald (Pittsburgh) or Timmy Jernigan (Florida State)? Lots of questions for the Bears to answer. If they go with Mosley though, the Bears won’t be disappointed. Mosley started four years at the most dominant college football program in America: Alabama. He learns quickly, he is a tackling machine, he makes very few mistakes, and he’s a “team-first” guy.

15.   Pittsburgh Steelers    -    Marqise Lee, USC, WR, 6-0 192 lbs, Junior
Ben Roethlisberger could use some help in the passing game. Enter…Marqise Lee. If Lee entered the 2013 Draft, he would have been a Top 3 pick, but he was too young, and, therefore, ineligible to do so. Lee dominated the Pac-12 over the past three seasons (when healthy), and scourged defensive secondaries week-in and week-out. In 36 games at USC, Lee caught 248 passes for 2,655 yards and 29 TDs. He possesses elite speed and agility, and he should be a definite playmaker for a Steelers offense that has been lackluster since the departure/injuries of Mike Wallace.

16.   Dallas Cowboys    -    Calvin Pryor, Louisville, FS, 5-11 207 lbs, Junior
17.   Baltimore Ravens    -    Justin Gilbert, Oklahoma State, CB, 6-0 202, Senior
18.   New York Jets    -    Odell Bekcham Jr., LSU, WR, 5-11 198 lbs, Junior
19.   Miami Dolphins    -    Louis Nix III, Notre Dame, DT, 6-3 331 lbs, Junior 
20.   Arizona Cardinals    -    Ryan Shazier, Ohio State, OLB, 6-1 237 lbs, Junior
21.   Green Bay Packers    -    Stephon Tuitt, Notre Dame, DE, 6-6 304 lbs, Junior
22.   Philadelphia Eagles    -    Brandin Cooks, Oregon State, WR, 5-10 189 lbs, Junior
23.   Kansas City Chiefs    -    Jace Amaro, Texas Tech, TE, 6-5 265 lbs, Junior
24.   Cincinnati Bengals    -    Bradley Roby, Ohio State, CB, 5-11 194 lbs, Junior 
25.   San Diego Chargers    -    Kelvin Benjamin, Florida State, WR, 6-5 240 lbs, Sophomore 
26.   Cleveland Browns    -    Johnny Manziel, Texas A&M, QB, 6-0 207 lbs, Sophomore 
27.   New Orleans Saints    -    Aaron Donald, Pittsburgh, DT, 6-1 285 lbs, Senior
28.   Carolina Panthers    -    Zack Martin, Notre Dame, OT, 6-4 308 lbs, Senior 
29.   New England Patriots    -    Jason Verrett, TCU, CB, 5-10 189 lbs, Senior
30.   San Francisco 49ers    -    Lamarcus Joyner, Florida State, CB, 5-8 184 lbs, Senior
31.   Denver Broncos    -    Timmy Jernigan, Florida State, DT, 6-2 299 lbs, Junior
32.   Seattle Seahawks    -    Xavier Su’a-Filo, UCLA, OG, 6-4 307, Junior 

All-Time Best: Running Back (NFL)

In order to evaluate each running back in a comprehensive manner, only running backs who have retired are included in these rankings.

1.       Jim Brown (1957-1965), 6-2 232 lbs.
College: Syracuse
Team: Cleveland Browns
Draft: 1957 - #6
Super Bowl Appearances: 4
Super Bowl Wins: 1
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
League Rushing Yards Leader: 8
NFL MVP: 3
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 6
1st Team All-NFL: 8
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 9
Career Stats: 12,312 rushing yards, 106 rushing TD’s, 5.2 yards per carry, 104.3 rushing yards per game, 2,499 receiving yards, 20 receiving TD’s


2.       Barry Sanders (1989-1998), 5-8 205 lbs.
College: Oklahoma State
Team: Detroit Lions
Draft: 1989 - #3
Super Bowl Appearances: 0
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 4
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 2
1st Team All-NFL: 6
2nd Team All-NFL: 4
Pro Bowls: 10
Career Stats: 15,269 rushing yards, 99 rushing TD’s, 5.0 yards per carry, 99.8 rushing yards per game, 2,921 receiving yards, 10 receiving TD’s


3.       Walter Payton (1975-1987), 5-10 200 lbs.
College: Jackson State
Team: Chicago Bears
Draft: 1975 - #4
Super Bowl Appearances: 1
Super Bowl Wins: 1
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 1
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 5
2nd Team All-NFL: 3
Pro Bowls: 9
Career Stats: 16,726 rushing yards, 110 rushing TD’s, 4.4 yards per carry, 88.0 rushing yards per game, 4,538 receiving yards, 15 receiving TD’s


4.       Marshall Faulk (1994-2005), 5-10 210 lbs.
College: San Diego State
Teams: Indianapolis Colts, St. Louis Rams
Draft: 1994 - #2
Super Bowl Appearances: 2
Super Bowl Wins: 1
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 0
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 3
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 3
Pro Bowls: 7
Career Stats: 12,279 rushing yards, 100 rushing TD’s, 4.3 yards per carry, 69.8 rushing yards per game, 6,875 receiving yards, 36 receiving TD’s


5.       Emmitt Smith (1990-2004), 5-9 210 lbs.
College: Florida
Teams: Dallas Cowboys, Arizona Cardinals
Draft: 1990 - #17
Super Bowl Appearances: 3
Super Bowl Wins: 3
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
League Rushing Yards Leader: 4
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 4
2nd Team All-NFL: 1
Pro Bowls: 8
Career Stats: 18,355 rushing yards, 164 rushing TD’s, 4.2 yards per carry, 81.2 rushing yards per game, 3,224 receiving yards, 11 receiving TD’s


6.       LaDainian Tomlinson (2001-2011), 5-10 221 lbs.
College: TCU
Teams: San Diego Chargers, N.Y. Jets
Draft: 2001 - #5
Super Bowl Appearances: 0
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 2
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 3
Pro Bowls: 5
Career Stats: 13,684 rushing yards, 145 rushing TD’s, 4.3 yards per carry, 80.5 rushing yards per game, 4,772 receiving yards, 17 receiving TD’s


7.   O.J. Simpson (1969-1979), 6-2 212 lbs.
College: USC
Teams: Buffalo Bills, San Francisco 49ers
Draft: 1969 - #1
Super Bowl Appearances: 0
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 4
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 5
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 6
Career Stats: 11,236 rushing yards, 61 rushing TD’s, 4.7 yards per carry, 83.2 rushing yards per game, 2,142 receiving yards, 14 receiving TD’s


8.       Eric Dickerson (1983-1993), 6-3 220 lbs.
College: SMU
Teams: L.A. Rams, Indianapolis Colts, L.A. Raiders, Atlanta Falcons
Draft: 1983 - #2
Super Bowl Appearances: 0
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 4
NFL MVP: 0
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 5
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 6
Career Stats: 13,259 rushing yards, 90 rushing TD’s, 4.4 yards per carry, 90.8 rushing yards per game, 2,137 receiving yards, 6 receiving TD’s

9.       Terrell Davis (1995-2001), 5-11 210 lbs.
College: Georgia
Teams: Denver Broncos
Draft: 1995 - #196
Super Bowl Appearances: 2
Super Bowl Wins: 2
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
League Rushing Yards Leader: 1
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 2
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 3
Career Stats: 7,607 rushing yards, 60 rushing TD’s, 4.6 yards per carry, 97.5 rushing yards per game, 1,280 receiving yards, 5 receiving TD’s


10.       Thurman Thomas (1988-2000), 5-10 210 lbs.
College: Oklahoma State
Teams: Buffalo Bills, Miami Dolphins
Draft: 1988 - #40
Super Bowl Appearances: 4
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 0
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 2
Pro Bowls: 5
Career Stats: 12,074 rushing yards, 65 rushing TD’s, 4.3 yards per carry, 66.3 rushing yards per game, 4,458 receiving yards, 23 receiving TD’s


11.   Earl Campbell (1978-1985), 5-11 232 lbs.
College: Texas
Teams: Houston Oilers, New Orleans Saints
Draft: 1978 - #1
Super Bowl Appearances: 0
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 3
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 3
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 5
Career Stats: 9,407 rushing yards, 74 rushing TD’s, 4.3 yards per carry, 81.8 rushing yards per game, 806 receiving yards, 0 receiving TD’s


12.   Curtis Martin (1995-2005), 5-11 210 lbs.
College: Pittsburgh
Teams: New England Patriots, N.Y. Jets
Draft: 1995 - #74
Super Bowl Appearances: 1
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 1
NFL MVP: 0
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 1
2nd Team All-NFL: 2
Pro Bowls: 5
Career Stats: 14,101 rushing yards, 90 rushing TD’s, 4.0 yards per carry, 83.9 rushing yards per game, 3,329 receiving yards, 10 receiving TD’s


13.       Marcus Allen (1982-1997), 6-2 210 lbs.
College: USC
Teams: L.A. Raiders, Kansas City Chiefs
Draft: 1982 - #10
Super Bowl Appearances: 1
Super Bowl Wins: 1
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
League Rushing Yards Leader: 1
NFL MVP: 1
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 2
2nd Team All-NFL: 1
Pro Bowls: 6
Career Stats: 12,243 rushing yards, 123 rushing TD’s, 4.1 yards per carry, 55.1 rushing yards per game, 5,411 receiving yards, 21 receiving TD’s


14.       Franco Harris (1972-1984), 6-2 230 lbs.
College: Penn State
Teams: Pittsburgh Steelers, Seattle Seahawks
Draft: 1972 - #13
Super Bowl Appearances: 4
Super Bowl Wins: 4
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
League Rushing Yards Leader: 0
NFL MVP: 0
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 2
2nd Team All-NFL: 1
Pro Bowls: 9
Career Stats: 12,120 rushing yards, 91 rushing TD’s, 4.1 yards per carry, 70.1 rushing yards per game, 2,287 receiving yards, 9 receiving TD’s



15.   Edgerrin James (1999-2009), 6-0 220 lbs.
College: Miami
Teams: Indianapolis Colts, Arizona Cardinals, Seattle Seahawks
Draft: 1999 - #4
Super Bowl Appearances: 1
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
League Rushing Yards Leader: 2
NFL MVP: 0
NFL Offensive Player of the Year: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 1
2nd Team All-NFL: 2
Pro Bowls: 4
Career Stats: 12,246 rushing yards, 80 rushing TD’s, 4.0 yards per carry, 82.7 rushing yards per game, 3,364 receiving yards, 11 receiving TD’s

Best of the Rest
16. Tony Dorsett (1977-88)
17. Shaun Alexander (2000-08)
18. Gale Sayers (1965-71)
19. Leroy Kelly (1964-73)
20. Jerome Bettis (1993-2005)
21. Ricky Watters (1992-2001)
22. Eddie George (1996-2004)
23. Roger Craig (1983-93)
24. Tiki Barber (1997-2006)
25. Clinton Portis (2002-10)
26. Corey Dillon (1997-2006)
27. Jamal Lewis (2000-09)
28. Larry Csonka (1968-79)
29. Fred Taylor (1998-2010)
30. Ahman Green (1998-2009)
31. Brian Westbrook (2002-10)
32. Ottis Anderson (1979-92)
33. Lawrence McCutcheon (1972-81)
34. James Brooks (1981-92)
35. Herschel Walker (1986-97)
36. Lydell Mitchell (1972-80)
37. Warrick Dunn (1997-2008)
38. John Riggins (1971-85)
39. Ricky Williams (1999-2011)
40. Jamal Anderson (1994-2001)

Prior to the 1966-1967 NFL season, the “Super Bowl” was known as “NFL Championship” or “AFL Championship.” In order to keep comparisons between running backs consistent, players who won NFL or AFL Championships prior to the Super Bowl coming into existence are credited with “Super Bowl Wins” in this analysis.

All-Time Best: Quarterback (NFL)

In order to evaluate each quarterback in a comprehensive manner, only quarterbacks who have retired are included in these rankings.


1.       Joe Montana (1979-1994), 6-2 200 lbs.
College: Notre Dame
Teams: San Francisco 49ers, Kansas City Chiefs
Draft: 1979 - #82
Super Bowl Appearances: 4
Super Bowl Wins: 4
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 3
Playoff Winning Percentage: 69.6%
NFL MVP: 2
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 2
Pro Bowls: 8
Career Stats: 40,551 passing yards; 273 passing TD’s, 139 INT, 63.2 CMP%, 
211.2 yards per game, 92.3 QB Rating


2.       Brett Favre (1991-2010), 6-2 225 lbs.
College: Southern Miss
Teams: Green Bay Packers, N.Y. Jets, Minnesota Vikings
Draft: 1991 - #32
Super Bowl Appearances: 2
Super Bowl Wins: 1
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
Playoff Winning Percentage: 54.2%
NFL MVP: 3
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 3
Pro Bowls: 11
Career Stats: 71,838 passing yards; 508 passing TD’s, 336 INT, 62.0 CMP%, 
237.9 yards per game, 86.0 QB Rating


3.       Steve Young (1985-1999), 6-2 215 lbs.
College: BYU
Teams: Tampa Bay Buccaneers, San Francisco 49ers
Draft: 1984 - #1
Super Bowl Appearances: 3
Super Bowl Wins: 3
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
Playoff Winning Percentage: 57.1%
NFL MVP: 2
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 3
Pro Bowls: 7
Career Stats: 33,124 passing yards; 232 passing TD’s, 107 INT, 64.3 CMP%, 
196.0 yards per game, 96.8 QB Rating; 4,239 rushing yards, 43 rushing TD's


4.       John Elway (1983-1998), 6-3 215 lbs.
College: Stanford
Teams: Denver Broncos
Draft: 1983 - #1
Super Bowl Appearances: 5
Super Bowl Wins: 2
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
Playoff Winning Percentage: 66.7%
NFL MVP: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 4
2nd Team All-NFL: 1
Pro Bowls: 9
Career Stats: 51,475 passing yards; 300 passing TD’s, 226 INT, 56.9 CMP%, 
220.0 yards per game, 79.9 QB Rating; 3,407 rushing yards, 33 rushing TD's


5.       Otto Graham (1946-1955), 6-1 196 lbs.
College: Northwestern
Teams: Cleveland Browns
Draft: 1944 - #4
Super Bowl Appearances: 10
Super Bowl Wins: 7
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 3
Playoff Winning Percentage: 75.0%
NFL MVP: 3
1st Team All-NFL: 7
2nd Team All-NFL: 1
Pro Bowls: 5
Career Stats: 23,584 passing yards; 174 passing TD’s, 135 INT, 55.8 CMP%, 
187.2 yards per game, 86.6 QB Rating


6.       Dan Marino (1983-1999), 6-4 228 lbs.
College: Pittsburgh
Teams: Miami Dolphins
Draft: 1983 - #27
Super Bowl Appearances: 1 
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
Playoff Winning Percentage: 44.4%
NFL MVP: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 3
2nd Team All-NFL: 5
Pro Bowls: 9
Career Stats: 61,361 passing yards; 420 passing TD’s, 252 INT, 59.4 CMP%, 
253.6 yards per game, 86.4 QB Rating

7.       Johnny Unitas (1955-1973), 6-1 194 lbs.
College: Louisville
Teams: Baltimore Colts, San Diego Chargers
Draft: 1955 - #102
Super Bowl Appearances: 4
Super Bowl Wins: 3
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
Playoff Winning Percentage: 75.0%
NFL MVP: 3
1st Team All-NFL: 6
2nd Team All-NFL: 1
Pro Bowls: 10
Career Stats: 40,239 passing yards; 290 passing TD’s, 253 INT, 54.6 CMP%, 
190.7 yards per game, 78.2 QB Rating


8.       Kurt Warner (1998-2009), 6-2 214 lbs.
College: Northern Iowa
Teams: St. Louis Rams, Arizona Cardinals
Draft: 1994 - Undrafted
Super Bowl Appearances: 3
Super Bowl Wins: 1
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
Playoff Winning Percentage: 69.2%
NFL MVP: 2
1st Team All-NFL: 2
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 4
Career Stats: 32,344 passing yards; 208 passing TD’s, 128 INT, 65.5 CMP%, 
258.8 yards per game, 93.7 QB Rating


9.       Fran Tarkenton (1961-1978), 6-0 190 lbs.
College: Georgia
Teams: Minnesota Vikings, N.Y. Giants
Draft: 1961 - #29
Super Bowl Appearances: 3
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
Playoff Winning Percentage: 54.5%
NFL MVP: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 2
2nd Team All-NFL: 1
Pro Bowls: 9
Career Stats: 47,003 passing yards; 342 passing TD’s, 266 INT, 57.0 CMP%, 
191.1 yards per game, 80.4 QB Rating


10.       Bart Starr (1956-1971), 6-1 190 lbs.
College: Alabama
Teams: Green Bay Packers
Draft: 1956 - #200
Super Bowl Appearances: 6
Super Bowl Wins: 5
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 2
Playoff Winning Percentage: 90.0%
NFL MVP: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 2
2nd Team All-NFL: 2
Pro Bowls: 4
Career Stats: 24,718 passing yards; 152 passing TD’s, 138 INT, 57.4 CMP%, 126.1 yards per game, 80.5 QB Rating


11.       Jim Kelly (1986-1996), 6-3 217 lbs.
College: Miami
Teams: Buffalo Bills
Draft: 1983 - #14
Super Bowl Appearances: 4
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
Playoff Winning Percentage: 52.9%
NFL MVP: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 1
2nd Team All-NFL: 2
Pro Bowls: 4
Career Stats: 35,467 passing yards; 237 passing TD’s, 175 INT, 60.1 CMP%, 
221.7 yards per game, 84.4 QB Rating


12.       Troy Aikman (1989-2000), 6-4 220 lbs.
College: UCLA
Teams: Dallas Cowboys
Draft: 1989 - #1
Super Bowl Appearances: 3
Super Bowl Wins: 3
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
Playoff Winning Percentage: 73.3%
NFL MVP: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 1
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 6
Career Stats: 32,942 passing yards; 165 passing TD’s, 141 INT, 61.5 CMP%, 
199.6 yards per game, 81.6 QB Rating


13.       Len Dawson (1957-1975), 6-0 190 lbs.
College: Purdue
Teams: Pittsburgh Steelers, Cleveland Browns, Kansas City Chiefs
Draft: 1957 - #5
Super Bowl Appearances: 3
Super Bowl Wins: 2
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
Playoff Winning Percentage: 62.5%
NFL MVP: 1
1st Team All-NFL: 2
2nd Team All-NFL: 2
Pro Bowls: 7
Career Stats: 28,711 passing yards; 239 passing TD’s, 183 INT, 57.1 CMP%, 
136.1 yards per game, 82.6 QB Rating


14.       Roger Staubach (1969-1979), 6-3 195 lbs.
College: Navy
Teams: Dallas Cowboys
Draft: 1964 - #129
Super Bowl Appearances: 4
Super Bowl Wins: 2
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 1
Playoff Winning Percentage: 64.7%
NFL MVP: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 2
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 6
Career Stats: 30,700 passing yards; 153 passing TD’s, 109 INT, 57.0 CMP%, 
173.3 yards per game, 83.4 QB Rating


15.       Donovan McNabb (1999-2011), 6-2 240 lbs.
College: Syracuse
Teams: Philadelphia Eagles, Washington Redskins, Minnesota Vikings
Draft: 1999
Super Bowl Appearances: 1
Super Bowl Wins: 0
Super Bowl MVP Honors: 0
Playoff Winning Percentage: 56.3%
NFL MVP: 0
1st Team All-NFL: 0
2nd Team All-NFL: 0
Pro Bowls: 6
Career Stats: 37,276 passing yards; 234 passing TD’s, 117 INT, 59.0 CMP%, 223.2 yards per game, 85.6 QB Rating; 3,459 rushing yards, 29 rushing TD’s

Best of the Rest
16.   Boomer Esiason (1984-97)
17.   Warren Moon (1984-2000)
18.   Rich Gannon (1987-2004)
19.   Dan Fouts (1973-87)
20.   Sammy Baugh (1937-52)
21.   Steve McNair (1995-2007)
22.   Terry Bradshaw (1970-83)
23.   Bobby Layne (1948-62)
24.   Y.A. Tittle (1948-64)
25.   Ken Anderson (1971-86)
26.   Norman Van Brocklin (1949-60)
27.   Drew Bledsoe (1993-2006)
28.   Joe Namath (1965-77)
29.   Phil Simms (1979-83)
30.   Jeff Garcia (1999-2011)
31.   Bob Griese (1967-80)
32.   Sonny Jurgenson (1957-74)
33.   Mark Brunell (1993-2011)
34.   Randall Cunningham (1985-2001)
35.   Ken Stabler (1968-84)
36.   Joe Theismann (1971-85)
37.   George Blanda (1949-75)
38.   Trent Green (1993-2008)
39.   Jim Plunkett (1971-86)
40.   Bert Jones (1973-82)

Prior to the 1966-1967 NFL season, the “Super Bowl” was known as “NFL Championship” or “AFL Championship.” In order to keep comparisons between quarterbacks consistent, players who won NFL or AFL Championships prior to the Super Bowl coming into existence are credited with “Super Bowl Wins” in this analysis.